European law cases

VAN GEND EN LOOS(1963) and COSTA v ENEL (1964)  European law takes precedence over national law. The Van Gend case was a Dutch case that involved a conflict between Dutch and EEC law over custom duties.

COSTA v ENEL (1964)

In this case it was argued that the Italian courts were obliged to follow domestic law which conflicted with European Law. However, the ECJ held that “the member states have limited their sovereign rights…and have created a body of law which binds the nationals and themselves.”

FACTORTAME cases (1990-2000)

This case involved Spanish Fishermen operating in UK waters. The Thatcher Government introduced legislation to limit such fishing to UK companies. It was held in this case that a state is liable to compensate for breaches of Community Law ñ this involved Spanish Fishermen and the Merchant Shipping Act 1988.  This case emphasises that EU law is supreme over domestic laws. 

It was held here that the Merchant Shipping Act 1988 contravened Treaty provisions regarding discrimination on nationality. The ECJ said that joining the EU was voluntary and therefore the UK had chosen to limit their sovereign rights

 BULMER v BOLLINGER (1974)

The treaty is like an incoming tide. It flows up the estuaries and up the rivers. It cannot be held back.