Monday, 7 April 2014

Judicial precedent - an overview


Criminal courts and lay people - an overview

Criminal courts, appeal courts and classification of offences
·         100% of criminal cases start in the magistrates court
·         Magistrates deal with things like bail and legal aid
·         If the case is triable either way then it will take place in the Crown court with a judge and a jury
·         If defendant wishes to appeal he would appeal to Court of Appeal
·         Can appeal against conviction and sentence
OR
·         Can also appeal to the Queen’s Bench Divisional Court of the High court on a point of law
·         Final appeal is to the Supreme court

Role and powers of lay magistrates
·         Adult court – deal with criminal cases for ages 18+
·         Youth court – hear cases for people ages 10-17
·         Decide on guilt and sentence
·         Deal with bail applications and conditions for bail
·         Deal with transfer hearings

Advantages of lay magistrates

Advantage
Cross section of society
Involves members of community and wide section of society than professional judges
49% of magistrates are women
Local knowledge
They know about local events, patterns of crime and local people’s opinions
Cost
Cheaper to have unpaid magistrate
Cost of unpaid magistrate is £52.10 per hour and is cheaper than a District judge which is £61.78
Few appeals
Few defendants appeal and those that do against are sentenced not guilty
Saves time


Law and morals updates

David Cameron to oppose new assisted dying bill